Comfort Food Restaurant in Buffalo, NY
At Anderson’s Frozen Custard, we’re more than just great frozen custard. We’re a full service comfort food restaurant offering something for everyone. Try our award winning All Natural Roast Beef, All Natural Turkey or Grilled All Natural Chicken sandwich with a side of Curly-Que French Fries or a Buffalo, NY favorite like our Buffalo Style Chicken Tender Sandwich.
Open all year long, warm up with our All Natural Chili, Mashed Potatoes, or Macaroni & Cheese. Anderson’s Frozen Custard is the ultimate comfort food restaurant serving Buffalo, NY and surrounding areas!
All Natural Roast Beef
Serving Roast Beef since 1964!
All Natural Roast Beef- 3 ounce$5.39
Our famous, all natural and award winning roast beef is slow roasted daily, and freshly sliced when you order. served with our savory au jus, salt, and pepper on your choice of roll: the famous kimmelweck, kaiser or whole grain
All Natural Roast Beef Carl's Choice- 5 ounce$6.39
A huge portion of our signature tender all natural roast beef piled high with great taste on your choice of any of our bakery fresh rolls: the famous kimmelweck, kaiser, or multigrain. Named after our founder Carl Anderson, who obviously knew his beef.
Our thick and tangy homemade barbecue sauce sautéed with pieces of our lean, juicy all natural roast beef, served on a bakery fresh sesame seed roll.
World Bistro- All Natural Roast Beef Italiano
Our famous tender slow roasted all natural beef topped with peppers, onions and provolone cheese. Try it with chicken or turkey.
World Bistro- Greek All Natural Roast Beef$6.24
Our famous tender slow roasted all natural beef topped with red onion, crisp leaf lettuce, crumbled feta cheese and served with greek dressing. Try it with chicken or turkey.
World Bistro- Mexicana All Natural Roast Beef$6.24
Our all natural roast beef stuffed in a wrap with guacamole, chipotle sauce, salsa, lettuce, red onion and hot pepper cheese.
World Bistro- Ida Mashed All Natural Roast Beef$6.24
Our all natural roast beef, smothered with mashed potatoes, sharp cheddar cheese, crispy onion rings and covered with bistro sauce.
Select a Roll or Bread
Rolls- Kimmelweck, Whole Grain, Kaiser
Soft Sesame Breads- Wheat, Rye, White, and white wraps
GLUTEN FREE plain Roll - add $2.00*
*Learn more about our gluten free menu options.
Select your Condiments
Horseradish, ketchup, mustard, mayo, lettuce & tomato, onion, relish, bistro sauce, chipotle sauce, dijon sauce, original BBQ sauce, pickles, banana peppers.
Salsa, Mashed Potatoes, Onions & Peppers,Cheddar Sauce, Thick Roast Beef or Turkey gravy
Select Your Cheeses$0.54
Sliced Provolone, American, Cheddar, Hot Pepper, Swiss, Feta or Blue Cheese Dressing
From The Grill
Sahlen's Charboiled Hot Dog$2.24
Locally owned Sahlen's smokehouse hot dog char grilled to perfection, and served on a bakery fresh roll. Add your favorite fixings to make this all-american favorite your own tasty creation.
All Natural Cheeseburger$4.53
A delicious, all natural beef burger char grilled to perfection, topped with your choice of favorite cheese, and served on a bakery fresh roll. Add your favorite fixings to make this all-american favorite your own tasty creation.
In the mood for something healthy and delicious - try a tasty vegetable patty char grilled to perfection, topped with cool, crisp lettuce and juicy tomato, and served on a bakery fresh whole grain roll.
Select your Condiments
Ketchup, mustard, mayo, lettuce & tomato, onion, relish, bistro sauce, chipotle sauce, dijon sauce, orignial bbq sauce, pickles, banana peppers.
Select your Cheeses$0.54
American, Cheddar, Provolone, Hot Pepper, Feta, Blue Cheese Dressing
Select your Extras$0.99
Chili, Guacamole, Bacon Strips, Onion Rings
All Natural Chicken & Wild Caught Fish
Buffalo Style Tender Sandwich$5.19
Two all natural white meat chicken tenders smothered with spicy, buffalo style wing sauce and creamy blue cheese dressing on a soft, bakery fresh sesame roll with cool, crisp lettuce.
All Natural Chicken Tender Basket$8.19$5.19
Delicious, lightly breaded all natural white meat chicken tenders served plain or with your choice of one of our finger Licking good 'ol buffalo wing sauce and a side of crunchy golden fries. choose from our cool ranch dressing, or creamy blue cheese dressing for dipping. Small or large sized basket.
Wild Caught Fish Filet Sandwich$5.49
A delicious, lightly breaded fish filet served on a soft, bakery fresh roll with cool, crisp lettuce and our own tasty tartar sauce.
Flame-Broiled All Natural Chicken Sandwich$4.99
Juicy, tender, all natural white meat chicken flame broiled to perfection with cool, crisp lettuce and juicy tomato on a soft, bakery fresh sesame roll.
World Bistro- All Natural Chicken in the Grass$5.24
Char grilled all natural chicken breast topped with steamed spinach, red onion, melted provolone and balsamic vinaigrette dressing. try it with roast beef or turkey.
All Natural Turkey
All Natural Turkey$4.99
All natural flavor. looking for something low sodium. try slices of our moist and delicious turkey on your choice of bakery fresh role. Served hot or cold.
Old Fashioned All Natural Turkey$5.48
All natural turkey on your choice of bread smothered with thick turkey gravy. No comfort food restaurant is compete without a hot, open-faced sandwich like our signature all natural turkey.
Select ANY Regular Size or Larger Sandwich, ANY Side Item, ANY Drink and save on your order.
Soup & Chili
All Natural Chili$4.59$3.59
On a cold day, nothing warms you up like a bowl of mouthwatering all natural chili from Anderson's! We are the ultimate comfort food restaurant offering all of your heart warming favorites all winter long. Available in a cup or bowl.
savor the flavor by the spoonful! your taste buds will sing at the steaming selection of our mouthwatering soups. Whether it's a light lunch or a savory meal companion, our soups will put a smile on your face as they warm you from the inside out. You will be sure to add Anderson's to your favorite comfort food restaurants after trying our delicious hot soups. Selections vary each day. Our soups are perservative free! Available in cup or bowl.
Fresh mixed greens tossed with crumbled feta cheese, juicy mandarin oranges, and crunchy pecans with tangy low fat raspberry vinaigrette.
Oriental Mandarin Salad$6.99
Tender fire-grilled all natural chicken breast, almonds, juicy mandarin oranges, carrots, and crunchy chow mein noodles on a bed of mixed greens with a tangy orange sesame dressing.
All Natural Turkey Garden Salad$6.99
Fresh and crisp mixed greens tossed with three ounces of tender all natural white meat turkey, cheddar cheese, refreshing cucumber, and juicy tomato. Prefer our famous roast beef instead of turkey? Just ask!
Fresh mixed greens with cucumber and tomato. Available in small and large sizes.
Fresh mixed greens with cucumbers, tomatoes, feta cheese, banana peppers, and onions with Greek dressing.
Fries, Rings, & Things
Curly Que French Fries$1.99
Nothing is more classic American than a steamy hot side of fries. Anderson's uses fresh Idaho potatoes to create delicious additions for any meal.
Sweet Potato Fries
Another comfort food restaurant classic, we serve our sweet potato fries with honey and butter for dipping.. making these a classic with a kick!
Cajun Fries with Cheese$2.49
Curly Que fries with a zesty twist of spices and melted cheddar sauce on the side for dipping.
Lightly battered onion, fried to golden brown perfection. from a simple snack to a sensational side dish.
Yes you read that right, fried pickles! Enjoy a side of ranch for dipping these delectably different sides.
Fresh, steaming hot, oven-baked Idaho potatoes. Your choice of plain, butter, or chives.
Additional Toppings: Broccoli, BBQ beef, sour cream, cheese, gravy, bacon.
Homestyle Mac & Cheese$3.59
Continuing our tradition as Buffalo, NY's favorite comfort food restaurant, try our homestyle Macaroni & Cheese - sure to warm your soul all the way through!
Mashed Potatoes with Gravy$2.49
Includes choice of One kid's sized main item, One side and One drink PLUS a free ice cream cone token!
Kids Main Item Choices$5.99
All Natural Roast Beef, BBQ Beef, Turkey, Sahlen's Hot Dog, All Natural Chicken Tender, Jr Burger, Mac & Cheese, PBJ, PB & Banana.
Kids Side Item Selections
Curly Fries, Mandarin Oranges, Apple Sauce, Banana, Pretzels or Chips.
Kids Drink Selectons
Chocolate Milk, Apple Juice, Pop.