Our Menu

A comfort food restaurant with something for everyone

At Anderson’s Frozen Custard, we’re more than just great frozen custard. We’re a full service comfort food restaurant offering something for everyone. The Buffalo News called us ‘the ultimate comfort food restaurant in Buffalo, NY’ – we believe you will agree! Try our award winning All Natural Roast Beef, All Natural Turkey or Grilled All Natural Chicken sandwich with a side of Curly-Que French Fries or a Western New York favorite like our Buffalo Style Chicken Tender Sandwich.

Anderson’s lunch & dinner menu has grown over the years and is as widely beloved as our signature desserts and frozen treats. Our friendly staff prepares our mouth watering slow roasted all natural beef fresh every day, hours before opening and throughout the day. We have grown our menu by offering increasingly more all natural products to provide our guests with the highest quality ingredients and the best tastes for lunch, dinner and dessert. Of course, we balance our local favorites like the Buffalo Style Chicken Tender Sandwich and Classic All Natural Beef on Weck with all of your favorite comfort food restaurant classics – homestyle Macaroni & Cheese, hot soups (flavors rotating daily), Mashed Potatoes and Loaded Baked Potatoes & Fries. For a contemporary delectable combination, our Ida Mashed All Natural Roast Beef sandwich includes our famous roast beef, slice of cheddar cheese, hot mashed potatoes, crispy onion rings and a delicious bistro sauce! Finally, our Vegan options include a Black Bean Veggie Burger, Veggie Wrap and of course our Create-Your-Own-Salad option.

Open all year long, warm up with our All Natural Chili, Mashed Potatoes, or Macaroni & Cheese. Anderson’s Frozen Custard is the ultimate comfort food restaurant serving Buffalo, NY and surrounding areas!

  • Lunch & Dinner
  • Desserts
  • Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Roast Beef Sandwiches


  • Original All Natural Roast Beef
    $6.19
    3 oz
  • Carl's Choice All Natural Roast Beef
    $7.19
    5 oz.
  • Barbecue Beef - all natural roast beef sauteed in our own BBQ sauce
    $5.19
  • Roast Beef Italiano
    $8.07
    All Natural Roast Beef topped with Peppers, Onions and Provolone Cheese.
  • Greek Roast Beef
    $7.13
    All Natural Roast Beef topped with Red Onion, Leaf Lettuce, crumbled Feta Cheese and served
    with Greek Dressing.
  • Ida Mashed Roast Beef
    $9.01
    All Natural Roast Beef, Mashed Potatoes, Cheddar Cheese and Onion Rings smothered in Bistro sauce.
  • Roast Beef & Mac ‘n Cheese
    $7.48
    w/Bold BBQ Sauce
  • Old Fashioned Roast Beef
    $7.13
    w/thick gravy on organic sprouted bread
    Original—3 oz.

Turkey Sandwiches and More


  • Original
    $6.19
    3 oz. (Served hot or cold)
  • Carl's Choice
    $7.19
    5 oz.
  • Old Fashioned Turkey
    $7.13
    w/thick gravy on bread Original–3 oz.
  • Bacon Cheddar Turkey BBQ
    $8.42
    All Natural Turkey with Cheddar Cheese, Nitrate Free Bacon, Red Onion and Bold BBQ Sauce
  • Veggie Wrap
    $4.89
    Avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, veggie slaw, & Balsamic on the side

Chicken & Wild Caught Fish


  • Buffalo Style Chicken Tender Sandwich
    $6.29
    with Lettuce, Wing Sauce, Blue Cheese
  • Chicken Tender Basket
    with Fries Plain or Buffalo Style
    Small
    $6.49
    Large
    $9.49
  • Grilled All Natural Chicken
    $6.29
  • Asiago Caesar Chicken Wrap
    $7.23
    w/almonds
  • Chicken in the Grass
    $8.17
    Char Grilled All Natural Chicken breast topped with steamed spinach, red onion, melted provolone and balsamic onion jam.
  • Wild Caught Fish Sandwich
    $6.29
  • Wild Caught Haddock Fish Fry
    $12.99
    *During Lenten Season

Grill Items


  • Cheeseburger
    All Natural Angus Beef
    Single
    $5.93
    Double
    $7.63
  • Veggie Burger
    $6.19
  • Hot Dog
    $2.99
    Sahlen’s
  • Salmon Burger
    $6.89
    w/Spicy Chili Sauce

Hot Sides


  • Soup
    Preservative free
    Cup
    $4.39
    Bowl
    $5.39
  • All Natural Chili/Chowder/Stew
    Cup
    $4.19
    Bowl
    $5.19
  • Homestyle All Natural Mac ’n Cheese or Chili—Mac ’n Cheese
    Cup
    $4.39
    Bowl
    $5.39
  • Baked Potatoes
    Plain, Buttered or with Chives 2.19
    Add Toppings:
    Nitrate Free Bacon, BBQ Beef, Chili — 1.19
    Sour Cream, Broccoli, Cheddar Sauce, Thick Gravy — .89

Fries, Rings & Things


  • Curly Que Fries
    Small
    $2.54
    Large
    $3.89
  • Cajun Fries with Cheese
    Small
    $3.19
    Large
    $4.79
  • Onion Rings
    Small
    $3.19
    Large
    $4.79
  • Fried Pickles with Ranch Dip
    $3.19
  • Sweet Potato Fries w/Honey
    Small
    $3.19
    Large
    $4.79
  • Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
    $2.74

Salads


  • Create Your Own Garden Salad
    $4.59
    Start with a base of Mixed Greens
    & carrots, then select your toppings:

    Includes your choice of:

    Croutons, Banana Peppers, Cucumber,
    Tomato, Chow Mein Noodles, Red Onion,
    Parmesan Cheese

    Salad Extras—add .94 each
    Broccoli, Pecans, Almonds, Mandarin Oranges,
    Feta Cheese, Cheddar Cheese,
    Marble Blue Jack

    Add Protein to your Salad —
    BBQ Beef. - add 2.99
    Salmon Burger - 4.59
    All Natural Roast Beef or Turkey—add 3.99
    All Natural Grilled Chicken—add 4.49
    All Natural Chicken Tender—add 3.99
    Nitrate Free Bacon—add 1.29
    Avocado—add 1.99
    Dressings— Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Greek,
    Raspberry Vinaigrette, Asiago Caesar, Orange Sesame
    GRILLED CHICKEN MANDARIN SALAD 10.86
    Mixed Greens, Carrots, Grilled Chicken, Mandarin Oranges,
    Almonds, Chinese Noodles & Orange Sesame Dressing.
    Spring Salad 7.26
    Mixed Greens, Carrots, Feta Cheese, Red Onion & Pecans,
    Mandarin Oranges with Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing.
    Side Salad 2.99
    Potato Salad 1.99
    Mandarin Orange Fruit Cup 1.60
  • Grilled Chicken Mandarin Salad
    $10.56
  • Spring Salad
    $7.41
  • Potato Salad
    $2.19
  • Mandarin Orange
    $1.70

Kids Meals


Includes Choice of Kid’s Sized: Main Item, Side and Kid’s Drink Cup ... plus a Free Cone Token

  • Choose One Main Item
    $6.99
    All Natural Roast Beef, BBQ Beef, All Natural
    Turkey, Hot Dog, All Natural Chicken Tender,
    PB & J, Junior All Natural Hamburger, Mac ’n Cheese,
    Peanut Butter & Banana Sandwich
  • Choose One Side Dish
    Curly Fries, Mac ‘n Cheese, Mashed Potatoes, Mandarin Oranges, Fruit & Veggie Pouch, Banana, Pretzels or Chips* Cajun Fries, *Sweet Potato Fries, *Plain Baked Potato, *Soup —add .30
  • Choose One Beverage
    Chocolate Milk, Apple Juice Box, Pop
    * Mini-Shake—add 1.00

Smoothies


Dairy or Non-Dairy

  • Blueberry Pomegranate
    $4.39
  • Mango
    $4.39
  • Pina Colada
    $4.39
  • Lemonade
    $4.39
  • Strawberry Banana
    $4.39
  • Cappuccino Smothered with Chocolate or Caramel
    $4.39

Strawberry Sensation


  • Strawberry Sensation
    No Fat & Non-Dairy Original Lemon Ice blended with Lemon Up & Strawberries
    Regular
    $3.59
    Large
    $4.64

Beverages


  • Soft Drinks
    Regular
    $2.09
    Large
    $2.29
  • Coffee
    Small
    $1.79
    Large
    $2.29
  • Hot Chocolate
    Small
    $1.79
    Large
    $2.29
  • Hot Tea
    Small
    $1.79
    Large
    $2.29
  • Bottled Water
    $1.99
  • Bottled Pop
    $2.29
  • Java Mocha
    $2.29
  • Java Cow Float
    $3.59
  • Iced Coffee
    $1.79
  • Hot Chocolate Ice Cream Float
    $3.59
Font Resize
Contrast