Ice Cream Cakes & Pies in Buffalo, NY

Handmade Ice Cream Cakes Made in BufFalo

Anderson’s Frozen Custard makes our own Handmade Ice Cream right here locally in Buffalo, NY. From our line of specialty Handmade Ice Cream Cakes including our Rich Chocolate Ganache Series, or our Premium Signature Ice Cream such as Cookie Dough & Rainbow Fudge with M&M’s to our Handmade Ice Cream Pies including Peanut Butter Fudge or Turtle, you won’t be disappointed.

Our ice cream cakes cater to the season! Anderson’s is proud to offer a unique selection of ice cream cakes and pies to cater to your guests. Need a Buffalo Bills-themed dessert for the big game? Whether you’re looking for a specialty design or festive balloon & cone birthday design, we have exactly what you’re looking for. Each of our ice cream cakes & pies may be personalized upon pickup.

Online Catering orders must be placed by 2:00pm two days prior to the requested pick up date.

Please Note: We are unable to process promotional coupons online. (If you have a coupon you will need to place your order in-store. One coupon per order.) Gift cards are accepted.

Download Catering MEnu

Specialty Ice Cream Cake Creations

Have you tried our premium Ganache Ice Cream cakes? Whether you splurge on a peanut butter fudge or mint fudge ganache ice cream cake, your taste buds will never be the same! Our ganache cakes feature our famous handmade ice cream, cookie crunch and a topping of our delicious chocolate fudge ganache. These ice cream cakes are a special treat for your next birthday celebration, graduation, or corporate event. Oh my Ganache!

Whether it is a special occasion to celebrate or you want to make everyday an occasion, our Frozen Desserts will be the coolest! Ask your server to personalize your ice cream cake or pie with your special message!

Order Ice Cream Cakes for Pickup

Choose Your Variety

Our Handmade Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Browse our current handmade ice cream cake & pies selection at any of our six, family-owned Buffalo, NY area locations.

Order Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Traditional Small Round Cake with Sprinkles

Vanilla and Chocolate Ice Cream with a center layer of chocolate crunch and topped with frosting.

Traditional Small Round Cake with Flowers

Vanilla and Chocolate Ice Cream with a center layer of chocolate crunch and topped with frosting.

Buffalo Bills Small Round Ice CreaM Cake

A layer of vanilla handmade ice cream, and a layer of chocolate handmade ice cream with chocolate crunchies in between decorated to cheer on our favorite team!

Specialty Cookies & Cream Dream Ice Cream Cake

Oreo Ice Cream with real Oreos and rich Fudge and Frosting.

Mint Ganache Ice Cream Cake

Chocolate Mint Ice Cream with a center layer of chocolate fudge and cookie crunch, topped with Mint Chunk Ice Cream and all smothered in rich fudge ganache!

Turtle Ice Cream Pie

Chocolate and Vanilla Ice Creams with hot fudge, caramel, crunchy pecans in a chocolate graham crust.

Ice Cream Catering Packages

Invite Anderson's to your Next party

Anderson's provides everything you need to host your next party, corporate event or birthday! From all-natural roast beef sliced by the pound, handmade ice cream cakes & pies and so much more, invite Anderson's to your next gathering!

À La Carte Ordering