Event Catering in Buffalo, NY

Event Catering & Party Planning

Feature Anderson’s event catering for your next party or corporate gathering! Order in Group Meals or à la carte with our Party 2 Go package featuring our all natural roast beef on weck, all natural turkey, all natural grilled chicken, barbecue beef, plus many handmade sides and favorites for your guests. We also offer boxed and bagged lunches in classic or customized versions with your guests’ names & specific selections.

Our Frozen Dessert event catering packages include handmade ice cream cone or sundae bar options complete with full service staff or can be set up for pick-up or drop off only. Your guests will love creating their favorite sundae as they select from rich hot fudge, strawberries, sprinkles, candies, whipped cream & more! While the children enjoy the process of building their own frozen creation, adults too rewind the hands of time and experience a simple pleasure we can all appreciate – ice cream!

Anderson's now offers pre-ordered Sundae Kits! Our Scoopfuls of Fun Sundae Package serves 6-8 and includes your selection of frozen dessert, sundae sauce toppings, candy toppings, nuts and even whipped cream. Try either of these packages for your next order-in family night!

Please Note: We are unable to process Coupons online. (If you have a coupon you will need to place your order in-store. One coupon per order.)

Event Catering Packages

Classic Sundae Fun Pack

Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Ready to Serve Sundae Bar

Ice Cream Dishes

Party Food 2 Go

Boxed or Bagged Lunches

What Our Guests' Say

Hi Holly! In the midst of cleaning up after my mom’s 80th yesterday, I had to take a minute to say “THANK YOU!!!” The party was a huge success! I so appreciated your help with the food ordering process! It was by far my biggest worry, but after talking it through with you, I was not worried at all! Now…the food! Delivery was perfectly on time! The delivery person was extremely polite and professional, got the food where it needed to go, explained everything and was off before most even realized he had been here. Kudos to this young man! Please thank him for us!The packaging was incredible!!! Everything was hot, and fresh! Cold things were nice and chilled. It was all delicious! All of our guests gave it rave reviews! The portioning of the beef was sooooo helpful for me! I was dipping and making sandwiches, and the portions were perfect! The rolls were super fresh, as well, and that is tough with the weck rolls. Again, all I can say is Thank You so much! You will be hearing from us, and I am sure some of our guests as well. One more thing…the cost was very reasonable and the quality was exceptional! Please feel free to pass on and share my comments! 5 stars for Anderson’s event catering!

Frequently Asked Questions

What sets Anderson’s Catering apart from others?

Not only are we proud to have been serving our WNY guests for over 75 years, we are proud to serve you more healthful, all natural catering options than many others in the Buffalo, NY area. Additionally, we have a dedicated Catering Coordinator to assist you with questions, planning ideas and customizing your entrée and dessert selections.

What catered items are All Natural?

Roast Beef, Turkey, Grilled Chicken, Mac & Cheese.

What does All Natural Mean?

These items have no preservatives and are hormone free. Read more about our nutrition.

What is different about your ice cream?

We make our ice cream ourselves! Yes it is all handmade! Over 20,000 gallons of ice cream are hand stirred, the old fashioned way at our very own ice cream plant on Sheridan Drive in Kenmore.

Do our foods contain allergens?

Many of our products contain or may come in contact with common allergens including wheat, peanuts, soy, tree nuts, milk, eggs, fish. Cross Contamination may occur in any of our facilities. For ingredients and nutritional information please see our web or ask the manager on duty at your nearest Anderson’s for details.

Can you deliver?

Yes, we offer delivery on all non-served items. See current order forms for delivery fees.

Can I pick items up at my local Anderson’s?

Yes you can! Please see order forms for timeframes required and check out our locations to learn more about each.

In the "Party Food To Go" package – what is the difference between a platter and a tin?

Tins are generally preferred for those opting to serve the all natural roast beef or all natural turkey hot. Platters are generally preferred for offering cold sandwiches.

If you are ordering our all natural roast beef in tins, the beef is cooked more rare and platters are cooked more medium.

How do I order?

Order catering packages online or you may call our Catering Director at 716–633-2302.

For questions, you may also e-mail us at catering@andersonscustard.com.

If I have ice cream delivered to me how long will it stay frozen?

We prefer to deliver your ice cream as close to serving time as possible. Ice cream sundae packages are delivered in boxes packed with cold chillers and foam to protect the product. With that said, you have a short window of approximately 30 minutes from the time we deliver before it will start to melt.*
*When the boxes are kept out of the sun and covered with a blanket provided by you.

For those who prefer we can deliver ice cream in our rentable “Silver Bullet Coolers” which will elongate the shelf life. These are just like an old fashioned beach cooler that is on wheels. It will keep tubs of ice cream and pre scooped dishes/sundaes frozen for up to 3 hours from the time it is delivered.*
*When kept closed and out of the sun and covered with a blanket provided by you.

The “silver bullet cooler” has a rental fee and an additional fee if not returned within 24 hours of use. (The silver bullet cooler can be returned to the closest Erie County Anderson’s location to you.)

What is the cancellation policy?

Orders cancelled less than 3 business days before the event date may incur a cancellation fee, regardless of type of order.

What if my group is tax exempt?

There is no tax charged to those groups with a tax exempt form.  If your group is tax exempt, please call our Catering Director to place your order 716-633-2302.

© 2022 Anderson's Frozen Custard

Website Design by ThinkForward Studios